The person who nominated this name did not provide any promotional pitch or reasons.
However, someone else with their tongue firmly in their cheek circulated a homework exercise for “The House of the Gentle Bunyip”, saying:
Why we should use this name:
- It has been used in the past but oldies have forgotten it and our youth have never heard of it.
- It is a seriously punchy name and insiders could shorten it to ‘Bunyip Church’ or even HGB
- Athol Gill – its founder who dies in 1992- is one of our saints – it makes a nice connection.
- The name is no longer a registered business name – the ABN has been cancelled, so we should grab the name
- It is very, very Australian.
- The Bunyip, like us, kind of lives in Cyberspace
- “Gentle” sugggests an achieveable standard of a caring community without projecting an unattainable boast.
- The Community Church of St Mark (Clifton Hill) has a stained glass window to honour Athol Gill, so it no longer . needs bunyips.
- We could substitute “Church” for “House” and remove the need to add a “part B” to the end of the name, thus: ” The Church of the Gentle Bunyip”
Why we might not use the name:
- A few very elderly bunyips are still alive
- The title is too long for those with a short attention span
- The link with mythology will unsettle some conservative christians
- It neither explicitly or implicitly says “Baptist”
p.s. There was a “Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster” – which practised Pastafarianism, but that is another story.
While I love the poetic and symbolic nature of this name, the actual project was attached to another church. If we were seriously considering it, we’d need to consult with them.
“Gentle Bunyip” is strongly associated with a very specific community that no longer exists, so I don’t think it can be used without it being heard as a claim to be the rebirth of that community.
The symbolism of this name does appeal to me. As too does the gentle (no pun intended) nod towards the history of contemplative worship in Melbourne.
One drawback is that there is an actual place in Gippsland called Bunyip and it could perhaps be a source of confusion with regard to being physically located there.
It doesn’t sound like us to me. I agree that “Gentle Bunyip” is strongly associated with a very specific community that no longer exists.